×

Garnet
Garnet

Carnelian
Carnelian



ADD
Compare
X
Garnet
X
Carnelian

Garnet Vs Carnelian

Add ⊕

Astrology

Origin

Australia, India
-

Color

Yellow, Green, Red, Pale pink, Violet-red, Brown, White, Colorless, Blue, pink
Red

Streak

White
White

For which Rashi?

Aries, Virgo, Capricorn, Leo, Aquarius
Taurus, Leo

Planet

Mars
-

Element of Planets

-
-

Energy

-
-

How to Wear?

Finger

-
-

Ring Metal

-
-

Deities

Persephone
Isis, Bragi

Not to wear with

-
-

Powers

Healing, Protection
Protection, Healing, Courage

Birthstone

Planetary

Scorpio
-

Talisman

Taurus
-

Physical Properties

Tenacity

-
-

Solubility

-
-

Durability

-
-

Specific Gravity

3.55-4.332.58-2.64
1 7.18
👆🏻

Fracture

Conchoidal, Uneven
Uneven, Splintery, Conchoidal

Cleavage

Indistinct
Absent

Mohs Hardness

6.5-7.56.5-7
2 10
👆🏻

Chemical Composition

Garnet is a series of several different minerals with unique chemical formulas.
SiO2

Optical Properties

Luster

Vitreous, Adamantine
Vitreous

Pleochroism

None
-

Dispersion

0.020.01
0.005 1
👆🏻

Transparency

Transparent, Transparent to translucent
Translucent, Transparent to nearly opaque

Refractive Index

1.730-1.8951.535-1.539
1 3.25
👆🏻

Optic Character

-
-

Crystal System

Trigonal
Trigonal

Birefringence

-99990.003-0.009
0 0.296
👆🏻

Clarity

Transparent
Translucent

Benefits

Physical

Neurological

Enhances mental clarity and focus
Enhances mental clarity and focus

Cardiovascular

-
Supports heart health

Respiratory

Good
Good

Reproductive

Supports reproductive health
-

Digestive

Supports digestive health
-

Psychology

Passion
Motivation

Healing

Physical healing
Emotional healing

Qualities Associated

Passion
Courage

Garnet Vs Carnelian Fracture

Fracture is an important parameter when you compare Garnet and Carnelian Physical Properties. It is necessary to understand the significance of these properties, before you compare Garnet Vs Carnelian fracture. Whenever a gemstone chip breaks, it leaves a characteristic line along its breakage. Such lines are known as fracture and are used to identify the gemstones in their initial stages of production when they are in the form of rough minerals. Fracture is usually described with the terms “fibrous” and “splintery” to denote a fracture that usually leaves elongated and sharp edges. Fracture observed in Garnet is Conchoidal and Uneven. Carnelian fracture is Uneven, Splintery and Conchoidal.

Garnet Vs Carnelian Luster

A primary knowledge about Garnet vs Carnelian luster is useful in apparent identifications of these gemstones. Luster is the measure of light that gets reflected when incident on a finished cut gemstone. There are two major types of lusters: Silky and Adamantine. Since luster varies between two crystals of even the same gemstone, luster is limited to basic identification criteria. Garnet exhibits Vitreous and Adamantine luster. Carnelian, on other hand, exhibits Vitreous luster.